Barnsley 3-3 Horsham
Seventh-tier Horsham earned an FA Cup first-round replay with League One side Barnsley after a thrilling six-goal draw at Oakwell.
The Tykes were ahead early on when Max Watters powered in a header from Jamie McCart's corner, but the Hornets levelled when Daniel Ajakaiye played in Shamir Fenelon to finish in style.
Horsham then stunned the hosts when James Hammond hammered home a penalty kick after Corey O'Keeffe brought down Ajakaiye, but Barnsley's Fabio Jalo curled a stunning equaliser into the top corner on the stroke of half-time.
Barnsley went back in front when Mael de Gevigney glanced home O'Keefe's corner and they wasted a host of chances before Tom Richards tapped in for the visitors following a lightning break from Jack Strange.
The two sides will meet again in Sussex on Tuesday, 14 November.
Sheppey United 1-4 Walsall
League Two side Walsall recovered from a goal behind to reach the FA Cup second round with a confident victory at non-league opponents Sheppey United.
James Bessey-Saldanha's spectacular strike from distance gave the hosts, who play four tiers below the Saddlers in the Isthmian League South East, hope of an upset with their only attempt of the first half.
Douglas James-Taylor levelled with a clever run and neat finish as Walsall's dominance paid off on a night when they reached the second round for the fifth time in six seasons.
